Puffy vs. Casper - Our 2022 Mattress Comparison Guide (2023)

The Casper Mattress is Good for...

• Those who want a mattress you can sink into, and feel it conform around the body.
• Those who sleep with a partner and are looking for motion isolation, so neither can feel movement from the other.
• Those with sensitive pressure points in shoulders, back, elbows, hips, or knees that get sore from sleeping.

The Puffy Mattress is Good for...

• Those looking for an affordable memory foam mattress in the medium-firmness range.
• Those who sleep with a partner and are easily disturbed by movement or noise.
• Those who live in locations with more extreme seasonal weather.

Sleep Position Ratings

Casper Mattress Sleeper Ratings

The Casper’s three-layer comfort system offers a conforming feeling, improved spinal alignment, and pressure point relief. The medium firmness makes it optimal for those in the average weight group (130 to 230 pounds), as well as side and back sleepers. The Capser is highly rated in motion isolation and makes almost no noise with movement, making it a good option for couples or those who wake easily from disturbances.

Puffy Mattress Sleeper Ratings

The Puffy mattress rates well for temperature neutrality thanks to the top two layers constructed with breathable foam that doesn’t trap heat in the mattress. This makes it a good option for sleepers who sleep hot or live in temperate climates. The Puffy mattress conforms to the body and gives the sleeper a feeling of sleeping in the mattress, rather than on top of the mattress. It rates “excellent” in both motion isolation and noise, making it a great choice for couples looking for undisturbed sleep. Based on our testing, sleepers under 230 pounds found it comfortable for all sleeping positions (back, side, and stomach).

• You like the feeling of a mattress hugging your body.
• You weigh 230 pounds or less.
• You experience frequent body aches and pains.
• You and/or your partner wake up easily from mattress noise or movement.

• You weigh 230 pounds or less.
• You are looking for a memory foam mattress that sleeps cool.
• You like the feeling of a mattress hugging your body.
• You are looking for a mattress that isolates movement.

Technical Details Comparison

Sizing and Pricing

Mattress Construction

Next let’s look at how the Casper and Puffy Mattress models are made. The table below lists firmness, thickness, weight, and composition specs for both beds.

How Is the Casper Built?

The Casper has three layers of comfort foam that provides a medium firmness. The top and bottom layers are polyfoam and the middle layer is memory foam. A high-density polyfoam base layer reinforces the bed and helps maintain an even and supportive sleep surface. It also has a soft polyester cover.

Together, these layers provide conforming support to the body and encourage spinal alignment during sleep. All three layers of foam are open-cell, meaning they’re breathable and allow hot air to escape. The Casper sleeps fairly cool compared to other memory-foam mattress.

The Casper isolates motion well and is almost silent when bearing weight. The queen size weighs 71 pounds, which is quite light for a memory foam mattress. Because of this, it’s easy to rotate the mattress as recommended.

How Is the Puffy Built?

The Puffy mattress is constructed with three foam layers. Puffy’s “cooling cloud” top layer is a non-latex foam that promotes ventilation, releasing any hot air. The cooling cloud layer allows the Puffy mattress to sleep much cooler than other foam mattresses. The center foam layer provides pressure relief on areas like shoulders, hips, and knees, that can suffer on an uncomfortable mattress. The bottom layer is a firm core support that promotes spinal alignment while sleeping.

The Puffy mattress cover is soft polyester and is stain resistant and machine washable. All components of the Puffy mattress are made in the US. The queen-size weighs 69 pounds, fairly lightweight for a memory-foam mattress.

Casper Sleep Trial, Warranty, and Delivery

Puffy Sleep Trial, Warranty, and Delivery